Compassion for Mary and Martha

Who are you more like Martha or Mary?

I’ve asked that question more times than I can remember. Today we were discussing it at the Widow’s Support group and a brand new thought occurred to me.

We typically associate Mary and Martha’s behaviors with their personalities and their spirituality. Whole books have been written about this: Having a Mary spirit in a Martha World.

Nice. But in this case, what if we consider their behavior in context.

These two women just lost their brother. There is no mention of any husbands, so they are either widowed or old maids by cultural standards. That means their source of support and sustenance was gone.

These women were facing a dire situation. Their brother died and the one guy they knew who could have possibly done something about it drug his feet getting there. Jesus waited three days after he received the news that Lazarus was dying…and then he showed up when Lazarus was four days in the tomb.

Now let’s consider their personalities.

Martha handled her stress by getting busy in the kitchen. Slamming some cupboards and banging some pans can be very therapeutic. At least for me…and Martha.

Martha didn’t stuff her feelings. She was not going to get an ulcer from swallowing her anger…or her grief. She walked right up to Jesus and let him know she was miffed…hurt…disappointed…confused. She poured out her heart. No, it wasn’t pretty. How could it be?

Why does her response to Jesus’ appearing at the house surprise us? Why does she earn bad girl points for expressing herself? She just lost her brother and the future was looking pretty terrifying.

And while she was at it she took a couple shots at Mary. Siblings do that sort of thing, too.

Mary. A very different kind of personality. Mary shuts down. Mary pulls inward. Mary may be angry, hurt, and confused…her expression is tears. Banging pots does nothing for her.

How do you handle your grief?

I remember when my dad died. He had cancer. He was at home and we had hospice services. He took his last breath around 6:00am. The funeral home came for his body around 7:00am. By 8:00am my mother had turned the once dining room turned hospice equipped dying room back into a dining room–you would never have known the room was used for anything else. She got busy, that’s how she handled her grief.

If you only had that snapshot of my mother she might have appeared cold and detached…but she wasn’t. She was just functioning the only way she knew how. And the hospice worker noted that she was responding according to her personality.

What if all the world had of you was a snapshot of your most difficult day? What would it say about you? Are you a banger or a weeper?

Actually, I’m not sure that’s the most important thing. Jesus doesn’t value Mary’s weepiness more than Martha’s banging. What he valued was that she brought it to him. So go ahead, bang the pans if that makes you feel better, but don’t forget to come to Jesus.

Author: tinamhunt

ESFP with a dash of ADD. Lover of the Word and words. The cup of my life is neither half empty or half full--it overflows! I'm blessed to be a blessing and I'm here to share the journey.

5 thoughts on “Compassion for Mary and Martha”

  1. Tina:
    As a Martha personality, I thank you for taking away some of the guilt. This scripture haunts me often as it is often preached that we are to be more like Mary. I struggle with this because the Mary personalities that I know get all the accolades for their great personality while we Martha’s are told we are too focused on the details. Relationships need both.


    1. I personally think we do a disservice to the text by trying to make one personality more valuable. It’s like saying we all need to climb out of the boat like Peter. In both cases there’s a much deeper message. I’m sorry that you have experienced preaching and teaching that fails to honor your God-given personality and gifts. You are such a caring person–in or out of the kitchen. Blessings.


  2. Insightful post, Tina. Vicki, I agree with you! I’m very detail oriented but I’m not necessarily up zooming around. I’m the skeptical one in the room. I wouldn’t be helping Martha but I might not be with Mary, either. I’d probably be off in the corner listening and examining everything that was said. Always questioning. Maybe that’s why my favorite part of teaching and writing is the research. I don’t want to say anything unless I KNOW it’s the truth.

    Some of us are workers, some are listeners, and some are questioners. God needs all of us in the Body of Christ.


    1. Thanks, Sherry. Your questioning nature reminds me of Nicodemus. He wasn’t satisfied until he came to Jesus with his questions and Jesus honored him with one of the most notable portions of scripture: For God so loved the world…Our personalities are the way God wired us and as we honestly live into them we honor the creator. I always wished I was more like the quiet, reflective Mary…but it’s not me. And thankfully God does require a OSFA (one size fits all) personality…those things never fit me. πŸ™‚


  3. This is a beautiful post. I need to come back to it and re-read when I’m more awake and can really consider both the Mary and the Martha in me. Thank you for writing this. πŸ™‚


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


Resources for Studying the Bible in its Historical Context


Processing with God: Narrative Lectionary, Liturgy, Prayers

Nazarenes United for Peace

Christian Education, Advocacy, Awareness, and Guidance for Action.

like color

β€œWhat a hideout: Holiness lies spread and borne over the surface of time and stuff like color.” ― Annie Dillard


(n): post-evangelical living a true, good life


A devotional blog by Shawn Thomas


Shining the Spotlight of My Life On Jesus...

%d bloggers like this: